Loading your local guide

Dagwood's Deli in Surfside Beach: Twenty Years, One Fire, and the Biggest Sandwiches on the South End

Dagwood's Deli in Surfside Beach is approaching 20 years after a 2025 kitchen fire, a community fundraiser, and a comeback that kept the South End institution going.

Category: guide  |  Published: 2026-11-16

Some Grand Strand names earn their keep over decades, and Dagwood's is one of them. The sandwiches started in downtown Myrtle Beach back in 1988. That original spot is gone now — but the Dagwood's down on Highway 17 in Surfside Beach is about to turn 20 years old, and the road it took to get there says a lot about why folks keep showing up.

Dagwood's Deli & Sports Bar crew in front of the Surfside Beach restaurant. Photo: Dagwood's Deli & Sports Bar, via the venue's Facebook page

A comic-strip name and a downtown start

Dagwood's served its first sandwiches in 1988 at the original location on Mr. Joe White Avenue in downtown Myrtle Beach. The name comes from Dagwood Bumstead of the Blondie comic strip, a man famous for building sandwiches taller than his head — and the kitchen took that as a job description: deli meats piled high on rolls baked in-house, with all the extras.

Jonathon Staton started working at Dagwood's fresh out of college and bought the business in 1998. In 2003 he opened Bumstead's Pub in the room next door, doubling the size of the original restaurant. The Surfside Beach location came next, in 2006, and a North Myrtle Beach location followed in 2022.

The fire, and the comeback

On January 2, 2025, a kitchen fire shut the Surfside Beach restaurant down and put more than 80 employees out of work in the middle of winter. Three weeks later, the community answered with the "Smoked & Stoked" fundraiser — a parking-lot party with BBQ plates, music, and raffles, with the proceeds going to the staff.

The rebuild took just over four months. Dagwood's reopened in May 2025, ribbon cutting and all, and the regulars went right back to their booths.

Then, that August, the story took its other turn. On August 30, 2025, the original Mr. Joe White Avenue location closed for good after 37 years — the building is home to Big Dave's Chews & Brews now. Just like that, the Surfside Beach store went from the second location to the keeper of the name: the oldest Dagwood's still standing, carrying on a tradition that started in 1988.

What to order

Dagwood's sandwich with sides. Photo: Dagwood's Deli & Sports Bar, via the venue's Facebook page

The rolls are baked in-house every day, and the sandwiches are built the way the name promises. The Italian sub is a longtime favorite. The Lynn Swann Dipper stacks turkey and roast beef on the same sandwich. The Gamecock has its own following, and the Famous Dagwood Burger comes piled on a brioche bun. The meatball and provolone sub and the shaved prime rib grilled cheese both have regulars who won't order anything else, and the fish and chips come out the way fish and chips ought to be.

Dagwood's deli sandwich with pasta salad. Photo: Dagwood's Deli & Sports Bar, via the venue's Facebook page

The starters carry the sports-bar side of the room: wings, fried pickles, buffalo shrimp, fried mushrooms, and soft pretzels built for a three-hour game. There are more than 50 TVs, a full bar with a deep list of craft and international beers, a covered patio, and trivia nights and daily specials in the mix. It reads like a deli at lunch and a neighborhood bar by the fourth quarter, and Surfside wouldn't have it any other way.

Go see it

Dagwood's Deli & Sports Bar sits at 600 Highway 17 N (US-17 Business) in Surfside Beach. The kitchen runs daily from 11 AM to 11 PM, and the bar pours later into the night — closing time varies, never later than 2 AM. Call (843) 828-4600 or find the menus at dagwoodsdeli.com.

The crew has been celebrating the 20th anniversary all year long, marking the 20th of every month — and the official anniversary lands December 15. Twenty years in Surfside, thirty-seven in the family. That's a lot of sandwiches.

So tell MBU: What's your Dagwood's order — the one you'd drive across the Strand for? And Surfside regulars, were you there the week it reopened? MBU wants to hear it in the comments.

#MyrtleBeachUnlocked